Say what?!
Yes, you read it right. Like your villains, your antagonists, fiends, and bad guys or girls.
Why? Well, that’s going to take a bit to explain. To get started let’s look at the following as it sums up my thoughts better than I can word them.
“In the old days villains had mustaches and kicked the dog. Audiences are smarter today. They don’t want their villain to be thrown at them with green limelight on his face. They want an ordinary human being with failings.”
-Alfred Hitchcock
You have to be realistic. Yeah, there are some pretty nasty people out there in the world who do some pretty mean things but a murderer doesn’t generally kill someone just because they’re bored. Either they’re trying not to get caught for something, revenge, or maybe they have some mental issues that stem from a poor childhood.
Someone trying to prevent your star character from achieving their goal is doing it for a reason. Either they want something from your character or they lose something if your character gets what they want.
You have to have balance. Think about it this way, okay, your bad guy, Jeff, doesn’t want your star character, Jane, to win an upcoming race. Okay, that’s a pretty neutral thought. Let’s add a little more to our plot. Jane has to win this race or she won’t have enough money to pay off some other villain who’s kidnapped her sister. That’s a pretty good motivation to win the race.
Now, remember Jeff doesn’t want Jane to win the race. Why? Well, maybe his mother is sick and the prize money would pay for her treatment. They both want to win the race. They both need the prize money for really good reasons. So, what is it that makes Jeff the villain and Jane the heroine of this story?
How they go about getting what they want.
Jane is honest and works hard everyday for a month, sometimes running till she’s too tired to make it back home at night. Practice, practice, practice. That’s her motto.
Jeff practices too because he really needs that money and has to do everything he can to get it. So, he puts tacks in Jane’s running shoes, messes with the track, and lies to try and have her disqualified. If you didn’t know his mother was sick you’d think he was just being cruel for no reason and while to your main character that’s the way things might seem, it won’t make much sense to your readers.
What does this have to do with liking your evil-doer?
Everything.
Pick out one of your favorite characters. Not one of your own because that’s too hard for this little experiment but your favorite from a book you’ve read or a show you’ve watched recently. What is it you like about them most? What makes them so appealing? I’m not talking about looks or attitude but in reference to their plots.
If you’re like me and many others you might have a thing for the underdog, someone who doesn’t seem to have a chance but doesn’t give up no matter what and even when things get tough and tears are streaming down their faces they still manage to hang on by a thread. You might have a thing for the character who is self assured when trouble rises and seems so strong that it doesn’t phase them. Or maybe you like the character who does whatever is needed to be done without complaining and they don’t stop until it’s done.
These are just three basic types of heroes who happen to have a lot in common but what is that main thing that attracts us all to them?
Passion.
Your villain has to have a passion too. They’re passionate about getting what they want. Reasons aside, even if you ignore the why of what they’re doing they still have to be good at it. Yeah, a fumbling villain could be kind of funny and easy to mock but is that what you’re aiming for? Or do you want the kind of character your readers will love to hate? Maybe you want your readers to eventually sympathize with your bad guy? Or, if you’re writing horror, to fear him or her? Either way, your villain needs passion and in order to give it to him or her you as the writer need to have a deeper understanding of them.
Even if you never tell readers that Jeff’s mom is in the hospital- you need to know this so you can give him passion.
“I like villains because there’s something so attractive about a committed person — they have a plan, an ideology, no matter how twisted. They’re motivated.”
-Russell Crowe
Also, keep in mind that villains are people too and thus have feelings like everyone else. Alright, they might not always be human but they can still be angry, bored, annoyed, true- but they can also be frustrated, depressed, desperate, sad, or even in love no matter how sick and twisted they might go about expressing it. Unless you make them emotionless or invincible don’t let the little things slip by. You don’t need a building to fall on him to kill your bad guy. Emotions and a build up of tension could just as easily lead to his eventually downfall.
To sum it up:
“A villain must be a thing of power, handled with delicacy and grace. He must be wicked enough to excite our aversion, strong enough to arouse our fear, human enough to awaken some transient gleam of sympathy. We must triumph in his downfall, yet not barbarously nor with contempt, and the close of his career must be in harmony with all its previous development.”
-Agnes Repplier
Like your villain. Love them if you must. Why? Because without them you have no story. They are a tool, an alley, and an important asset for any scribe.
Rules of Writing